I will do developmental editing on your novel with a full manuscript critique
About this gig
I will do developmental editing on your novel with a full manuscript critique that shows you exactly why your story stalls and how to fix it, chapter by chapter.
Finishing a draft is a real achievement. Knowing what to do with it next is where most writers get stuck. A developmental edit is the big-picture pass that comes before line editing and proofreading: it looks at structure, character, pacing, point of view, plot logic, theme, and stakes, and tells you honestly what is working, what is not, and what to change first. I read your full manuscript as a careful, sympathetic reader who also understands craft, then deliver a critique you can actually act on.
What you get
- A full read of your complete manuscript, start to finish, with notes taken throughout (not a skim of the first chapters and a guess about the rest).
- An editorial letter (a detailed prose critique, typically 8–20+ pages depending on tier and word count) covering structure, plot, pacing, character arcs, point of view, voice, theme, tension, and stakes.
- A clear diagnosis of your manuscript's biggest structural problems, ranked by priority so you know what to fix first instead of drowning in everything at once.
- Chapter-by-chapter or scene-by-scene notes (Standard and Premium) that map where momentum dips, where information arrives too early or too late, and where the reader's investment rises or falls.
- Concrete, actionable revision suggestions — not just "this isn't working," but specific options for how you might fix it, with the trade-offs of each.
- Honest assessment of what is already strong so you don't accidentally revise away your book's best qualities.
- Margin / inline comments on the manuscript itself (Standard and Premium) flagging specific moments: a flat scene, a dropped thread, a character acting out of established motivation, an info-dump, a missed beat.
- Notes on genre expectations and market readiness where relevant — whether your opening earns a reader's trust, whether your ending pays off the promises of your premise.
- A short prioritized next-steps checklist so you finish the critique knowing precisely what your revision plan looks like.
Plans
| Basic | Standard | Premium | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Word count covered | Up to ~30,000 words | Up to ~70,000 words | Up to ~120,000 words |
| Full manuscript read | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Editorial letter | Concise (core issues) | In-depth | Comprehensive |
| Chapter-by-chapter notes | — | Yes | Yes |
| Inline / margin comments | — | Yes | Yes (detailed) |
| Prioritized revision plan | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Character & arc breakdown | Summary | Detailed | Detailed + per-character |
| Follow-up Q&A | — | One round | Two rounds + a call option |
| Typical turnaround | Shorter | Standard | Extended (longer book) |
Need a word count above the Premium range, or a series bible across multiple books? Message me first and I'll set up a custom scope so nothing important gets rushed.
How it works
- Message me before ordering. Tell me your genre, word count, where you are in the process, and what worries you most. I'll confirm the right tier and a realistic timeline.
- Send your manuscript as a DOCX (preferred) or clean Word-compatible file, double-spaced if possible. A one-paragraph synopsis and any specific questions help me focus the critique on what matters to you.
- I read the whole thing once for experience — as a reader, not an editor — so I can feel where the story grips and where attention drifts.
- I read again analytically, taking structural notes, marking the manuscript, and tracking arcs, threads, and pacing across the full book.
- I write your editorial letter and assemble the chapter notes and inline comments for your tier.
- I deliver the letter, the annotated manuscript, and your prioritized revision checklist.
- You ask follow-up questions (Standard and Premium) so anything unclear gets clarified before you start revising.
Why choose this
Developmental editing is about altitude. It's easy to find someone to fix your commas; it's much harder to find someone who will tell you that your protagonist has no real want until chapter nine, or that your midpoint reversal isn't actually a reversal, or that your subplot is quietly stealing energy from your climax. That diagnostic eye is what I bring.
I work with respect for the book you set out to write. My job is not to rewrite your novel into the one I would have written — it's to help your version become the strongest possible version of itself. That means honest feedback delivered kindly, with reasons, examples, and options rather than vague verdicts. You'll always understand why I'm flagging something, which makes the notes far easier to act on. And because I read the entire manuscript, the structural advice actually accounts for your ending, not just your opening.
Who it's for / use cases
- First-time novelists who have finished a draft and need an experienced, big-picture read before they revise or query.
- Writers preparing to submit to agents who want to know whether the manuscript holds up structurally before it lands in a slush pile.
- Self-publishing authors who want the story itself diagnosed before they invest in line editing, proofreading, and cover design.
- Experienced writers who are too close to the work and need an outside perspective on what's actually landing.
- Genre fiction authors (fantasy, sci-fi, romance, thriller, mystery, literary, YA, and more) who want feedback that respects their genre's conventions and reader expectations.
- Writers between drafts who have feedback fatigue from beta readers and need one coherent, prioritized professional opinion instead of ten contradictory ones.
FAQ
Q: Is this the same as proofreading or copyediting? No. Developmental editing is the high-level story edit: structure, character, plot, pacing, theme. It comes before line editing and proofreading. I won't be correcting every typo — I'll be telling you whether the story works. Fixing grammar before the structure is settled usually means polishing sentences you may end up cutting.
Q: Will you rewrite parts of my manuscript for me? No. This is critique and guidance, not ghostwriting. I'll show you precisely what isn't working and give you concrete options for fixing it, but the revising stays in your hands so the book stays yours.
Q: What genres do you work with? Most adult and YA fiction across literary and commercial genres — fantasy, science fiction, romance, mystery, thriller, historical, contemporary, and more. If you're unsure whether your project is a fit, message me with a short description before ordering and I'll tell you honestly.
Q: Will the feedback be harsh? It will be honest, specific, and thorough — but never cruel or dismissive. The point is to make your book better, not to make you feel bad. I always note strengths alongside problems, because knowing what to protect matters as much as knowing what to fix.
Q: My book is longer than the Premium word count. Can you still help? Yes — just message me first. I'll quote a custom scope and timeline so the longer manuscript gets the same careful read rather than a rushed one.
Q: How long will it take? It depends on your tier and word count, since I read every page. I'll give you a firm timeline when you message me before ordering, and I'd rather set a realistic date than promise a fast one I can't honor.
Q: What do I need to send you? A complete manuscript in DOCX or a Word-compatible format, ideally double-spaced, plus a short synopsis and any specific concerns. The more you tell me about what's worrying you, the more targeted the critique will be.
Q: Can we talk after I get the critique? Standard and Premium include follow-up Q&A so you can ask questions and make sure you understand the notes before you revise. Premium also includes the option of a call to walk through your revision plan together.
Reviews★4.8(4)
- @ninamedia★★★★★4
Really solid developmental feedback on structure and the sagging middle of my novel. Took a bit longer than I expected but the depth of the critique made it worth the wait.
- @alexp★★★★★5
I wasn't sure my plot holes were even fixable, but the critique laid them all out clearly and suggested ways to rework them. Felt like working with someone who actually read every page.
- @sophia2024★★★★★5
Got back a detailed editorial letter that dug into my character arcs and where the stakes weren't landing, and every note came with a reason, not just 'fix this.'
- @noracodes★★★★★5
The full manuscript critique was so thorough, it went chapter by chapter and pointed out exactly where my pacing dragged and where my subplots fell apart. Honestly reshaped my whole second act.